Say HBCU and many people think of the Bayou Classic, the often nationally televised football matchup between the Southern University Jaguars and the Grambling State University Tigers. Some fans would say that what is more important than the play of the football teams is the performance of the marching bands—in this case, the aptly named Southern University Human Jukebox (shown here), which performed with Lizzo on “Good As Hell” in 2019, and Grambling’s “World Famed” Tiger Marching Band, which performed with Beyoncé at Coachella in 2019.
HBCU fans are happy to root for their teams, but often the main attraction comes with the halftime performances, after which a good number of fans happily head for the gates at some schools.
HBCUs have found another path into the limelight with the election in 2020 of Kamala Harris, the first HBCU graduate to be elected vice president of the United States. Harris is a proud graduate of Howard University, the only federally chartered HBCU.
In a 2022 commencement address at Tennessee State University, she said that HBCUs are “a cathedral of education,” adding that HBCUs instill in their students the confidence to achieve their goals. “The value of this education is that it teaches you something very special—that yes, you can be anything and do anything.”
But HBCUs are about far more than football, marching bands, or even their esteemed alumni. Many HBCUs focus on preparing students for careers and professions as architects, cybersecurity specialists, educators, engineers, journalists, and scientists. Some have undergraduate programs in law, medicine, and veterinary medicine. A few have professional graduate programs in these subject areas. For example, Tuskegee University’s College of Veterinary Medicine in Alabama has produced 70 percent of the nation’s Black veterinarians since the program started in 1945.
HBCU history
The first HBCUs were founded in Pennsylvania and Ohio before the American Civil War (1861–65). Due to racial discrimination, Black youth were prohibited from attending exclusively white colleges and universities. These HBCUs, and then others, were established to provide Black youth with enough basic education to become teachers or enter trades.
There are several noteworthy firsts in the history of HBCUs. Cheyney University of Pennsylvania, founded in 1837 as the African Institute and later known as the Institute for Colored Youth, is widely considered the first HBCU. The first degree-granting HBCU was founded in 1854 as the Ashmun Institute in Pennsylvania and was renamed Lincoln University in 1866.
The oldest private HBCU is Wilberforce University, founded in 1856 in what is now Wilberforce, Ohio. It was funded largely by the Methodist Episcopal Church but closed in 1862. Additional funding by the African Methodist Episcopal Church in 1863 allowed it to reopen.
After the Civil War ended and slavery was abolished, more HBCUs were established with support from the Freedmen’s Bureau, a federal organization that operated during Reconstruction to help the formerly enslaved adjust to freedom. Some of these include Howard University, which took its name from Bureau Commissioner Oliver Otis Howard; Fisk University, in Nashville, Tennesse; and Atlanta University, now Clark Atlanta University, in Atlanta, Georgia.
Growing pains
Even as the number of HBCUs grew in the late 19th and 20th centuries, the vision and mission of the institutions—and who should chart their course for the future—was the subject of intense debate.
For example, there was significant disagreement about whether HBCUs should offer vocational training or a more traditional education. Further complicating the discussion was the fact that many of the early HBCUs were funded by and even run by prominent white educators, philanthropists, and business leaders.
Some leading and prominent African American leaders argued about whether Blacks were being adequately served by institutions so heavily controlled by white leadership. Most early HBCUs had white presidents. For example, Fisk University, founded in 1866, did not have its first Black president until 1946, when Charles Johnson took the helm.
Others argued that white leadership was the best way to establish a strong foothold and a strong foundation so the institutions could develop. Throughout the 19th and early 20th centuries, white philanthropists, including Andrew Carnegie, John D. Rockefeller, and Julius Rosenwald, provided funding to help establish HBCUs.
Some African American and white leaders questioned whether separate schools hindered broader efforts to move toward social and economic equality with whites, in a foreshadowing of a debate that would play out at the Supreme Court in the next century in the form of Brown v. Board of Education of Topeka.
According to Marybeth Gasman, a leading higher-education historian and the executive director of the Rutgers Center for Minority Serving Institutions, religion also played a key role in the early governance of HBCUs. The American Missionary Association helped found 11 HBCUs. “They considered people who had been slaves as people without Victorian morals—and that’s why they were doing it. They wanted to make them Christians,” she told Encyclopaedia Britannica in 2023.
And yet the intent was also undeniably educational. “These were the first institutions founded with the express purpose of educating recently freed Black people,” said Walter Kimbrough, who was president of Philander Smith College in Arkansas for seven years and president of Dillard University in New Orleans for 10 years.
Today there are about 100 HBCUs, and they are as diverse as majority-white private and public higher-education institutions across the nation. Some have small enrollments and are not known nationally. Others have enrollments of more than 10,000 students. Some have large endowments, compared with those of other HBCUs. Some have national and even international profiles.
Howard University, in Washington, D.C., and Hampton University, in Hampton, Virginia, are among the best-known HBCUs; Morehouse College and Spelman College, both in Atlanta, are in that group too. So is North Carolina A&T State University, in Greensboro, North Carolina. They have large endowments compared with those of other HBCUs. Each has graduate programs respected nationally. Nearly all HBCUs have majority-Black student populations and enroll students of all ethnicities, races, and nationalities. Dillard University, in New Orleans, Claflin University, in Orangeburg, South Carolina, and Tougaloo College, in Jackson, Mississippi, are HBCUs that have smaller enrollments and smaller endowments, some niche academic offerings, and small-college campus atmosphere. Bluefield State College, in Bluefield, West Virginia, has a student enrollment that is about 90 percent white. It was chartered as an HBCU and remains one today, even though demographic changes in West Virginia have radically changed its student makeup since its founding in 1895.
HBCUs have always strived for diversity. Even at their outset, “they were the first multicultural institutions,” notes Kimbrough, who was interim executive director of Morehouse College’s Black Men’s Research Institute in early 2023. “The public perception is that HBCUs are only for Black people, but they’ve never been only for Black people…. The first four students at Howard University were white,” he told Britannica in 2023.
More than HBCUs
Not all higher-education institutions with large African American student populations are called HBCUs. Some are Predominantly Black Institutions, or PBIs.
By definition, HBCUs are those mostly Black-serving institutions that were founded before 1964. Federal law has mandated that no HBCUs could be created after 1964. So educational institutions serving mainly Black students and founded after 1964 are called Predominantly Black Institutions. Some PBIs include Chicago State University and the University of Baltimore. There are also Minority Serving Institutions (MSI), a designation that includes HBCUs and Tribal Colleges and Universities (TCUs). Both started when Black and Indigenous people were refused or lacked access to majority or predominantly white higher-education institutions. Trinity Washington University, in Washington, D.C., is an MSI which is classified as a PBI and a Hispanic Serving Institution.
The challenges and promise of HBCUs in the 21st Century
The United Negro College Fund (UNCF) and the Thurgood Marshall College Fund are two of the most influential organizations that support HBCUs. The UNCF—popularly known for its iconic slogan, “A mind is a terrible thing to waste”—has 37 member institutions and an aim of “moving students to and through college,” in part by helping students prepare for college and helping institutions grow stronger by strengthening academic offerings and keeping tuition low. The Thurgood Marshall organization helps students with scholarships, professional development, and more at 47 institutions, including publicly supported HBCUs and PBIs.
HBCUs are not as well funded as Predominately White Institutions (PWIs), and they enroll larger percentages of low-income Black students. About 8 percent of students at PWIs were from low-income families. At HBCUs the number of low-income students was about 24 percent, many of them first-generation college students, according to a 2019 study from Rutgers University. According to data compiled by the UNCF, the HBCUs in the United States are 3 percent of the nation’s nearly 4,000 colleges and universities identified by the U.S. Department of Education. Yet about 20 percent of all African American graduates got their education at HBCUs. Of the African Americans who earn undergraduate degrees in science, technology, engineering, and mathematics (STEM), 25 percent of them graduate from HBCUs.
Philanthropy has continued to play a key role in the success of HBCUs. Of particular note is billionaire Mackenzie Scott’s 2022 donation of $560 million to HBCUs. Prominent Black leaders in politics, business, and the arts have long been significant contributors, including media mogul Oprah Winfrey and business entrepreneur Robert Smith.