The influence of recording

Composition

In 1967 a survey of hundreds of American composers indicated that they were almost unanimous in regarding the recordings of their works as being more important than either printed publication or live performances. Through recordings, composers gained not only an easy familiarity with the music of others but also a new medium for their own works.

The contemporary American composer and teacher Milton Babbitt, in a conversation in 1965 with the Canadian pianist Glenn Gould (who maintained his own reputation largely by means of records and broadcasts, rather than by concert performances), said:

We have all been affected as composers, as teachers, as musicians by recordings to an extent that cannot possibly be calculated as yet.…I don’t think one can possibly exaggerate the extent to which the climate of music today is determined by the fact that the total Webern is available on records, that the total Schoenberg is becoming available.

The use of the record as a medium had superficial beginnings as early as 1904 in Ruggero Leoncavallo’s song “Mattinata”, specifically written for the record according to the label. Later, in 1925, Stravinsky composed a piano piece, Serenade in A Major, expressly for the record medium, though it is also perfectly capable of being performed live. Ottorino Respighi’s Pines of Rome (1924) incorporates a recording of a nightingale’s song in its third movement. Much more important use of recording as a medium occurred toward mid-century in works fundamentally relying on recorded tape, such as Edgard Varèse’s Poème électronique, an 11-channel tape played through 425 speakers at the 1958 Brussels World Fair, and Morton Subotnick’s Silver Apples of the Moon (1967), an electronic work playable only as a recording.

Teaching

In music education the phonograph was early adopted as a tool in teaching both serious students and laymen. Teachers who could not illustrate musical examples at the piano found in records a means of demonstration. They could also bring entire orchestras into the classroom by means of the phonograph.

In 1930 the Columbia History of Music by Ear and Eye, a phonographic survey that became popular in music history classes, enabled many students—as well as many of their teachers—to hear for the first time such instruments as viols, lutes, virginals, clavichords, and harpsichords together with the then little-known music written for them. A half dozen years later another educational recorded project, L’Anthologie sonore, added impetus to this specialized field. By the 1960s the Baroque music of the 17th and 18th centuries—as well as the earlier music of the Renaissance and the Middle Ages—increasingly was recorded in performances using the instruments for which it was written. Such music found a wide audience beyond educational institutions; this audience was developed in large part by the phonograph.

By the late 20th century many conservatories, colleges, and universities, and even some secondary schools, had constructed recording studios to enable students to analyze their own performances or to rehear their own compositions.

Concerts

The impact of recordings on the concert hall was also enormous, both for classical and for popular performances. Performers in the 20th century could hardly hope to attract a concert audience if they had not produced distinguished recordings; usually, their audiences, both at home and abroad, consisted of persons who knew the performers’ work through recordings. In the popular music field especially, many performers could not compete in live appearances with recordings in which they depended heavily on technical aid. There were some who felt that the phonograph might cause the demise of live performance in the concert hall, which, if it survived at all, would do so for social rather than musical reasons. A possible indication of this trend was the disappearance of independent, nonacademic, nonprofessional classical music magazines in America; instead, there were record magazines. Their name changes are significant: The American Record Guide, established in 1935 as The American Music Lover; High Fidelity, established in 1951; and Stereo Review, established in 1958 as Hi Fi/Music Review. The record magazine was not a peculiarly American phenomenon; England had The Gramophone and Records and Recording; France, Diapason and Harmonie; Germany, HiFi Stereophonie and Fono Forum; Italy, Discoteca Hi Fi; Holland, Luister; Belgium, Hi-Fi Musique; Sweden, Musikrevy; and Japan, Record Art/Record Geijutsu, among many other periodical publications.

Musicology

The entire field of comparative musicology—i.e., the study of the relationships between Western and non-Western music—depends upon disc and tape recordings. Although the discipline may be traced to the 18th century, the field of study was improved with the invention of phonographic tools. Some non-Western music is transmitted orally rather than through a written tradition, and as such its performance practices—certainly in rhythm and intonation—cannot be accurately transcribed into Western notation. After World War II, anthropologists and musicologists visited the most remote parts of the world with tape machines to record aboriginal music before it was either tainted or wiped out by Western civilization.