The spatial illusions of Baroque paintings were beyond the limitations imposed by the stained-glass medium. The glass painter of the 17th and 18th centuries found himself reduced to completing the cycles of stained-glass windows in medieval churches or to creating contemporary art for an architecture with no artistic affinity with traditional stained glass. The most interesting development in the late 16th and early 17th centuries was the intimate and portable heraldic panel, which became fashionable to hang in domestic windows, particularly in Switzerland, the Low Countries, and Germany. These panels, seldom more than two feet high, are the glass painter’s showpieces; they complete the divorce between stained glass and architecture.

Painting glass with vitreous enamels in the 17th and 18th centuries led to the final decline of the art of stained glass. In the St. Janskerk windows at Gouda, Holland, painted by the brothers Wouter and Dirk Crabeth at the end of the 16th century, and in the works (1620–40) of Abraham and Bernard van Linge, the realization of the window as a translucent canvas painting is complete. Abraham van Linge’s windows painted in 1630 to 1640 for Christ Church Cathedral at Oxford are an excellent example of the destruction of the lead line as an integral part of the design. The leading simply holds together the square sheets of glass: the effect is the same as looking at a picture set behind a rectangular grid. This type of design was continued by English glass painters such as Henry Gyles and the Price and Peckitt families, all of York, Francis Eginton, and Sir Joshua Reynolds, who designed in 1778 the west window for New College Chapel, Oxford.

19th century

The Gothic revival that came as an offspring of the Romantic movement of the late 18th and early 19th centuries represents the beginning of a revitalization of the art of stained glass. The revival of interest in Gothic art stimulated an interest in both the technique and history of medieval glass painting. The pioneer figures in this field were E. Viollet-Le-Duc in France and Charles Winston in England. Winston was a lawyer and antiquarian who associated with various London glaziers and, with the technical help of James Powell and Sons, brought about a considerable improvement in the technical quality of coloured glass. In 1847 he wrote the first comprehensive study of the medium. The experiments were continued by W.E. Chance, who first successfully produced “antique” glass in 1863.

In the first half of the 19th century the styles and methods of the early Gothic period were reconstructed, but without much aesthetic appreciation of medieval art. Much of the work was stereotyped and mass-produced, particularly in Germany, and varied considerably in technical quality. The latter part of the century is dominated in England by Edward Burne-Jones and William Morris. Burne-Jones provided the designs and Morris adapted them to the medium of stained glass. In windows by them the lead line is once again treated as an integral part of the design, as seen, for example, in the windows for Christ Church at Oxford (1874–75 and 1878), Salisbury Cathedral (1879), and Birmingham Cathedral (1897). In the U.S. the works of John La Farge and Louis Comfort Tiffany were influential in creating an American interest in stained glass. Although the style and sentiment of 19th-century work has not been much in favour in the 20th century, the period had great historical significance in the revival of the basic technique of making stained glass.

Art Nouveau designers used stained glass decoratively for making such objects as lampshades and light fixtures, and turn-of-the-century architects increasingly employed stained glass as an integral element in wholly modern architectural settings: Victor Horta in his Hotel Solvay (1895–1910), Brussels; Antonio Gaudí in his Chapel of Santa Coloma de Cervelló (1898–1914) in the Güell Colony near Barcelona; Charles Rennie Mackintosh in the Willow Tea Rooms (1904), Glasgow; and Frank Lloyd Wright in the Coonley House (1908), Riverside, Illinois, and the Unity Church (1906), Oak Park, Illinois. These windows and panels clearly mark the beginnings of an authentically modern stained glass, despite their strictly ornamental intent.