By the time European artists arrived in the Americas in large numbers, Mannerism, a style characterized by artificiality and a self-conscious cultivation of elegance, had usurped the Renaissance style in popularity. The Spanish-trained painter Baltasar de Echave Orio established a dynasty of painters in Mexico that controlled official commissions there for three generations. This first Echave married the daughter of an important associate of Pereyns, Francisco Ibía (known as Zumaya), a skilled Mannerist. Echave painted in a shimmering Mannerist style during the early 17th century, well after the style had died out in most of Europe. Three of the 14 canvases he painted in 1609 for the retable of Santiago de Tlatelolco have survived: one, the Porziuncola, shows figures of Christ and the Virgin floating on clouds in front of a kneeling St. Francis. The compressed and distorted perspective of the scene is in the spirit of late Mannerism; all the holy figures have elongated bodies, stylized finger postures, and white zigzag highlights on their clothing. Two of this painter’s sons (surname Echave Ibía) continued the Mannerist style even longer.

In the later 16th century, the Viceroyalty of Peru, which included all of Spanish South America, attracted several important Italian artists. Bernardo Bitti was an Italian Jesuit who went to Lima about 1575. After working first on paintings at San Pedro in the viceregal capital, he went to a number of cities in the south highlands of what is now Bolivia and traveled twice to Ecuador. The size and shape of his long, large paintings suggest that they were originally intended to be placed in retables. His works from the turn of the 17th century are recognizably Mannerist—featuring elongated linear faces; swaying, gracefully curving, elongated bodies; and icy pastel colours—and recall those of Tintoretto in Italy and El Greco in Spain. His European viewers would have known the style was fashionable, but his indigenous viewers were also receptive to the exaggerated style, since they were not accustomed to naturalism. Bitti also carved low reliefs in the surrounds of some retables, such as those of Challapampa and the original retable in La Compañía of Cuzco, both in Peru, the figures of which have the recognizable Mannerist twist and elongation.

Other important Mannerist artists working in South America include Angelino Medoro, who practiced in what are now Peru and Colombia, using a Michelangelesque version of Mannerism. In 1617 he painted a deathbed portrait of the first saint of the Americas, known as St. Rose of Lima. Mateo Pérez de Alesio also utilized idealized Italianate imagery in true fresco applied to ceilings of churches in Lima, such as the Villegas Chapel in the Church of La Merced (1616), as he had done in Rome and Malta before immigrating to Peru in 1589. In Sucre, Bolivia, Cristóbal Hidalgo carved the choir stalls of the city’s cathedral; the figures there are framed by strapwork in a flat-relief northern Mannerist style.

Baroque

By the middle of the 17th century, the Baroque style of painting and sculpture had reached the Americas. Artists working in this style—some of them mestizo and mulatto, reflecting the increasing diversity of the region—preferred realistic directness and clarity and rejected the fantastic colours, elongated proportions, and illogical and extreme spatial relationships preferred by Mannerist artists. They strove to make the religious events depicted in their paintings seem realistic, causing viewers to feel as if they were participants. Painters of the early Baroque style rendered dramatically lit scenes of unidealized large-scale figures placed up against the front of the picture plane. This style, made famous by Caravaggio in Italy, became immensely popular with Spanish artists active in Seville, the city of departure for most Latin American settlers.

The Baroque painting style became established in Mexico with the work of the Spanish immigrant Sebastián López de Arteaga. In his monumental canvas Doubting Thomas (1643), the subject is beautifully attuned to the aims of the Baroque: the apostle Thomas inserts his finger in the wound in Christ’s side, leading the viewer to feel the presence of Christ and to experience his suffering. The life-sized protagonists on the canvas are surrounded by ordinary elderly men. From the left a single source of bright light spotlights the wound, emphasizing Christ’s fleshiness. Here “the Word has been made flesh,” embodying the purpose of Catholic Baroque art.

An anonymous painter known as the St. Jerome Master, based on the common theme of his work, employed the Caravaggesque style in Peru. His works include several half-length studies of St. Jerome—inspired by an Italian engraving—that show an aged man with a realistically furrowed brow, which is illuminated by a spotlight coming from his left side beyond the frame. The image seems to project in front of the plane of the frame, encouraging the sensation of the aging saint’s actual presence. Although his works are undated, the St. Jerome Master may well have been an important early painter of the Cuzco school, which comprised mainly Indian and mestizo artists.

In the early stage of the Baroque in Latin America, high-relief sculpture was used in facades and retables. In the church of San Francisco in Santafé de Bogotá, Colombia, for example, the wooden interior has a retable composed of square-framed biblical representations that were carved and painted anonymously in 1633. The scenes represent figures in rich tropical surroundings that suggest the lower altitudes of Colombia.

When the Baroque style extended to freestanding sculpture, early Latin American sculptors often chose to depict emotionally charged moments of Christ’s life in order to appeal to ordinary people, who could identify with Jesus’ suffering. These statues created in the viewer a sense of Christ’s physical presence by means of a life-size image, often dressed in actual garments. During major holy days these large wooden statues were paraded around the city on platforms carried by members of church fraternities. On the hill of Monserrate overlooking Santafé de Bogotá, a pilgrimage chapel contains Pedro de Lugo Albarracín’s powerful Baroque image of the Lord of Great Power (1656), which shows Christ tied to a low stake as he bleeds after a scourging. The figure, looking at the faithful in suffering and anguish, is at once one of the greatest works of Baroque art and an image charged with great religious power. Many statues of the Virgin similarly were dressed in real clothing in Spanish America, and they were often displayed in a special room (camarín) behind the altar. The convent of El Carmen in Quito, Ecuador, dedicated an entire room for a life-size sculptural representation of the death of the Virgin, with the polychromed wooden figure of the Virgin placed on a bed surrounded by her son’s disciples.

The most important inspiration to Latin American painters became the Flemish artist Peter Paul Rubens, whose art was known in the colonies through engraving and mezzotint copies. His paintings were reworked in numerous Latin American imitations, ranging from small painted marble slabs to huge canvases, and he created the grand manner used by Latin American nobility and the church for propagandist purposes. European Baroque sculpture supplanted the fine, balanced carving of the 16th-century Renaissance with more-compelling actively spatial carvings. Features of Baroque sculpture include life-size scale, realistic skin tones (encarnación), and the simulation of rich gold-threaded tapestry garments (which was achieved by estofado, or the application of coloured paint over gold leaf). Some Spanish Baroque masters, such as Juan Martínez Montañés, shipped their works to the Americas at the start of the 17th century.

As the Baroque became established in areas such as Mexico and Peru, paintings—increasingly inspired by Rubens—once contained within architectural frames of retables were now presented on freestanding colossal canvases. Paintings by the Mexican-born Cristóbal de Villalpando best exemplify this new scale in two great cathedrals of Mexico. In the sacristy of Mexico City Cathedral, between 1684 and 1686, he glued canvases on the walls and stabilized them with arched frames, which fit right under the vaults of the ceiling. Fresco painting in the 16th century had occupied a position similar to this, but rarely was it so large in scale. One of Villalpando’s paintings in the Mexico City sacristy, The Triumph of the Eucharist, is derived from cartoons by Rubens and shows a chariot pulling an aged pope. Villalpando was one of the few Latin American artists who utilized a Rubensian fluid brushstroke that simulated textures and communicated the urgency of the event depicted. He undertook illusionistic ceiling painting, the most quintessentially Baroque program, in a dome of Puebla Cathedral in 1688. He made the entire surface of the dome into an all-over composition of billowing clouds filled with angels and saints, from which descends a dove representing the Holy Spirit. The intense light of the cupola is meant to embody God’s universal grace. Through this grand manner, Latin American Baroque painters tried to capture the emotions of their viewers and to actively engage them in the church’s mission.

In Spanish South America (still included in the Viceroyalty of Peru in the beginning of the 18th century), the Baroque style was not introduced as emphatically as it was in Mexico. Scholars may be ignorant of the development of the Baroque there, however, both because many works are unsigned or otherwise poorly attributed and because earthquakes (such as the one that damaged Cuzco in 1650) destroyed the work of early Baroque artists. Once the Baroque was established there after 1650, however, informal workshops of Baroque painters coalesced in regional capitals.

Quito emerged as the most esteemed regional artistic centre in the Spanish American world. Among the important painters was Miguel de Santiago, a powerful mestizo artist who emulated such Spanish masters as Bartolomé Murillo in his portrayal of the Immaculate Conception. Of special interest are his secular allegorical depictions of subjects such as the four seasons. His successor, Nicolás Javier de Goríbar (1665–1740), created portrait cycles of full-length standing prophets as well as round medallions containing half-length kings of Judah. In sculpture the mestizo artist Bernardo de Legarda stands at the pinnacle of the Quito school. Beginning in 1734 Legarda carved masterful sculptures of the Virgin of the Apocalypse that reveal the spatial extension characteristic of Baroque sculpture from the period; because his twisting figures demanded more space than had previous sculptures, they could no longer be confined within a small niche of a retable. The deeply carved drapery of the figure in the cathedral at Popayán, Colombia, for example, has large folds that serve to emphasize her dynamic motion as she plunges her lightning bolt into the writhing serpent that symbolizes Satan. Legarda commanded a workshop of many assistants, which produced similar compositions of slightly lower quality.

Santafé de Bogotá emerged as another centre of Baroque in Spanish South America. Gregorio Vásquez de Arce y Cevallos, the finest painter there in the second half of the 17th century, depicted a wide range of monumental figures in print-derived landscapes that he executed with a sure hand in perspective, modeling, anatomy, and colour. In Potosí (now in Bolivia) in the late 17th century, Melchor Pérez de Holguín painted fluid renderings of biblical personalities and strikingly captured their individual emotional states.

In Brazil the end of the Baroque period is represented by the work of the sculptor and architect Antônio Francisco Lisboa, known as Aleijadinho (Portuguese: “Little Cripple”), the son of a Portuguese architect and an African woman. Aleijadinho built a series of small square structures along the zigzag path up to the Sanctuary of Bom Jesus de Matosinhos (begun 1757) in Congonhas do Campo (now called Congonhas). Inside each room he re-created scenes from the Passion of Christ in freestanding life-size polychrome wooden statues. Moving up to the sanctuary itself, he placed twisting soapstone figures of biblical prophets whose gestures reflect the turns of the double staircase leading to the top terrace. Their heavy features and faceted planes recall the wood-carving traditions of African sculpture.

Most of the time, Baroque art in Latin America served the interests of the church. However, beginning in the late Baroque, portrait painting depicting local nobility became a significant genre, particularly in works by the brothers Nicolás and Juan Rodríguez Juárez. This genre, based on European models, developed distinct tropes. For example, in Nicolás’s half-length portrait of the 2nd duke of Albuquerque (1693), he emphasized the status of the sitter by featuring the duke’s coat of arms in the upper-right corner of the painting and by adding a short inscription below, outside the painted frame. His younger brother, Juan, also emphasized rank in works such as a full-length portrait of the viceroy, the duke of Linares (1723), in which the sitter’s coat of arms is worked illusionistically into the curtain design, while a long inscription appears incised on the pedestal base of a column.