Phan Thanh Gian

Phan Thanh Gian (born 1796, Ben Tre province, Cochinchina [now in Vietnam]—died Aug. 4, 1867, Vinh Long) was a Vietnamese government official and diplomat whose conservatism and strict adherence to the political and ethical tenets of Confucianism may have contributed to the French conquest of Vietnam.

The son of a low-ranking administrative employee, Phan Thanh Gian was outstanding in state examinations and won a doctoral degree—the first awarded in Cochinchina (southern Vietnam)—and a position close to Emperor Minh Mang. At the imperial court he progressed rapidly through the scholarly ranks, becoming a mandarin of the second order and a counselor of the emperor. Following Confucian principles strictly, he informed his sovereign of errors and shortcomings in imperial edicts and practices, thus incurring imperial displeasure. Minh Mang deprived him of his titles and demoted him to fight as a common soldier in the region of Quang Nam, in central Vietnam.

On the battlefield, Phan Thanh Gian marched in the front lines and provided an example of courage and discipline. His behaviour won him the respect and admiration of officers as well as his fellow soldiers, and Minh Mang recalled him to court. Under succeeding rulers he was named to the highest governmental positions.

When the Vietnamese sovereigns began the active persecution of Christian missionaries, France invaded southern Vietnam and by 1862 had captured Saigon (now Ho Chi Minh City), Bien Hoa, and Vinh Long. In the Treaty of Saigon, Phan Thanh Gian ceded Gia Dinh and Dinh Thong (present-day My Tho), in the hope that the French would stay out of the remainder of Vietnam. The French thus controlled the richest parts of southern Vietnam, its three easternmost provinces.

In 1863 Phan Thanh Gian proposed a treaty by which France would halt its colonization efforts in Vietnam and return the three provinces in exchange for commercial settlements and land around Saigon, My Tho, and Mui Vung Tau (Cap Saint-Jacques), the promise of yearly tribute, and the provision that all of southern Vietnam would be declared a French protectorate. The terms were approved by France, and, although the emperor Tu Duc reneged on some points and added modifications that favoured the Vietnamese, the treaty was signed in 1864. The following year, however, France declared that it would respect only the terms of the original treaty. Phan Thanh Gian was dismayed, feeling that he had failed and had betrayed his people. He feared the influence of Western civilization and distrusted European technology. When the French seized lands that were under his personal protection in 1867, he committed suicide in protest of the use of force by the French in a cause for which they lacked any moral justification.