Shenouda III

Ecumenism and interfaith relations

From his consecration Shenouda reached out to other Christian churches. Under Shenouda the Coptic Orthodox Church increased its profile and activity in the World Council of Churches (WCC); the church had been one of the organization’s founding members in 1948. One of his first major actions as pope was to improve relations between the Coptic church and the Roman Catholic Church, which had been strained since the Council of Chalcedon in 451. The Coptic and other “Oriental” churches (Ethiopian, Armenian, and Syriac) had rejected the council’s statement on Christology (theological doctrine concerning the person and work of Jesus Christ) and were subsequently regarded in the West as heretical monophysites (believers in the doctrine that Jesus Christ had only a divine nature), though the Oriental churches vehemently denied the charge. In the second half of the 20th century, many of the Oriental Orthodox, or “non-Chalcedonian,” churches initiated dialogue with Eastern Orthodox churches with the aim of finally resolving the Christological issues. In 1973 Shenouda met the Roman Catholic pope Paul VI, becoming the first Coptic pope to visit Rome in more than 1,500 years. Shenouda and Paul began discussions that helped to resolve many of the ancient disputes and signed a joint statement affirming many tenets of Christology. Shenouda also helped to organize talks between the Oriental and Eastern Orthodox churches. In 1989 an Egyptian Coptic monastery hosted a meeting between representatives of Eastern Orthodoxy and Oriental Orthodoxy at which the two groups signed a joint Christological statement.

Shenouda increased the church’s profile outside the Middle East. In 1977 he became the first Coptic pope to visit the United States, and in 1996 the church appointed the first two U.S. diocesan bishops. Diocesan bishops were also appointed in Canada, Australia, and several South American countries.

Yet, despite that ecumenical impulse, relations with other churches during Shenouda’s reign were not without tension. In 1976 the Coptic Orthodox Church broke ties with the Ethiopian Orthodox Tewahedo Church, a fellow Oriental Orthodox church, after the new Marxist government of Ethiopia deposed the Ethiopian patriarch and installed a replacement. Relations with the Ethiopian church were further strained when, in the wake of Eritrea’s declaration of independence in 1993, Orthodox faithful in Eritrea appealed to Shenouda, who had honorary primacy among the Oriental Orthodox in Africa, for autocephalacy. Shenouda appointed a patriarch in 1994, and the Eritrean Orthodox Tewahedo Church became autocephalous in 1998. Relations between the Coptic and Ethiopian churches improved in 2007, though the churches had remained in full communion (members of each congregation could receive sacraments in the other) throughout the rift.

Shenouda’s outspoken criticism of Israel, particularly for its treatment of Palestinians, was hailed by some Copts but rejected by others. When Egyptian President Anwar Sadat announced a peace treaty with Israel in 1979, Shenouda banned Copts from making pilgrimages to holy sites in Israel. He said publicly that Muslims and Christians should enter the Holy Land “arm-in-arm,” and in 2001 he declared that he would enter Israel only on a Palestinian visa. In his criticism of Israel, Shenouda occasionally made comments about Judaism that some interpreted as anti-Semitic.

Are you a student?

Get a special academic rate on Britannica Premium.

Subscribe

Relationship with the Egyptian government

Because he represented a prominent religious minority in a predominantly Islamic country, Shenouda attempted to cultivate good relations with the Egyptian government. His relationship with Sadat began amicably but soon cooled, however. While Sadat attempted to broker peace with Israel in 1977–78, Shenouda renewed his sharp public criticism of Israel. When Copts were attacked by Islamic groups, Shenouda blamed Sadat for not doing enough to stop the violence. The relationship between the two leaders became increasingly tumultuous. In September 1981, following a row concerning public celebrations of Easter, Sadat dethroned Shenouda and exiled him to a desert monastery, installing Matta el-Meskin, Shenouda’s former teacher and then critic, as pope. After Sadat was assassinated in October 1981, his successor, Hosni Mubarak, eventually ended Shenouda’s exile and restored him to the papacy in 1985. Shenouda’s generally warm relationship with the authoritarian Mubarak was criticized by some Copts, particularly when Shenouda endorsed Mubarak’s reelection in 2005. When Islamic extremists killed 21 Copts by bombing an Egyptian church in January 2011, however, Shenouda rebuked Mubarak’s regime for not maintaining peace. After mass protests during the Egyptian Arab Spring led to Mubarak’s ouster in February 2011 (see Egypt Uprising of 2011), Shenouda, though in ill health, publicly praised the protesters.